"

7.0 Early American Policing

This photograph showcases the Seattle Police Department’s 15-officer motorcycle squad proudly displaying their new Indian brand motorcycles.
In the early days of 1910, the Seattle Police Department selected seven patrolmen to form the department’s inaugural “motor cops” squad. In a progressive initiative, the department invested $1,329 to acquire their first three motorcycles. This image, captured on October 22, 1914, features the Seattle Police Department’s motorcycle unit, which had since grown to include 15 officers, proudly presenting their newly acquired Indian brand motorcycles./ Photo Credit: Museum of History and Industry, Public Domain

OVERVIEW

In the tapestry of American history, policing is a dynamic thread woven into the fabric of society. This crucial element of the nation’s criminal justice apparatus has undergone several major transformations since its inception. The story of American law enforcement is a narrative of adaptations to societal changes, emerging challenges, and a continuous quest for balance between maintaining social order and protecting individual rights.

As we delve into this chapter, we embark on a journey through time, beginning with the early days of the American colonies when informal systems of community watch and constables operated as rudimentary forms of policing. Then we will proceed to explorations concerning the influence of societal forces and English common law on the early development and practices of formalized police departments in the 19th century. Next, we proceed to an overview of three subsequent policing eras during the 20th century, each characterized by substantial transitions to law enforcement strategy and notable modifications of approach.

This chapter aims to unravel the chronological narrative of policing in the U.S. by delving into the historical context that prompted strategic change and adaptive strategies, while also foreshadowing the ongoing challenges and debates that continue to shape the role of law enforcement in contemporary American society. By navigating the historical landscape of policing in the U.S., you will gain valuable insights into the intricate interplay between societal changes and the evolution of law enforcement institutions. As we commence on this journey through time, it is crucial to critically examine the historical context and challenges that have shaped the policing landscape in order to foster a deeper, enriched understanding of modern American law enforcement.

OBJECTIVES

  1. Examine the primary factors that propelled change in policing styles during each policing era.
  2. Identify and differentiate the roles and expectations of police officers throughout the three major policing eras.
  3. Examine cultural perceptions of police departments and analyze how these perceptions influenced changes in policing structure and approach.
  4. Analyze adaptive policing strategies that emerged as a specific result of dynamic societal forces and challenges.
  5. Describe the various policing styles used by law enforcement agencies and how this negatively affected various minority and ethnic groups.

KEY TERMS

  • Beat
  • Bobbies
  • Broken Window Theory
  • Community Policing
  • CompStat
  • Corruption
  • Exclusionary Rule
  • Hot Spots
  • Hue and Cry
  • Inequality
  • Keystone Cops
  • Law Enforcement Assistance Administration
  • Night Watch
  • Oppressive Systems
  • Patronage
  • Police Brutality
  • Popular Punitivism
  • Problem-Oriented Policing
  • Protests
  • Punitive
  • Racism
  • Rebellion
  • Riots
  • Slave Patrol
  • Social Injustice
  • Subpoenas
  • Thief-Taker Rewards
  • Uniform Crime Report
  • Vice Crimes
  • Wickersham Commission
  • Xenophobia
  • Zero-tolerance Policing

License

Icon for the Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0 International License

Introduction to the Criminal Justice System Copyright © 2025 by Courtney Crittenden is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0 International License, except where otherwise noted.